If God created everything, did GOD create Evil ? Albert Einstein



If God created everything, did GOD create Evil ? Albert Einstein

DailyMotion

Tune

YouTube

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 8.8/10 (16 votes cast)
If God created everything, did GOD create Evil ? Albert Einstein, 8.8 out of 10 based on 16 ratings

43 Comments Leave your comment

  1. GodzSlave says:

    God created EVERYTHING. Why? We don't know. We just have to go with it since GOD IS PERFECTION and CAN NEVER MAKE a mistake. We can't escape from God so our ONLY CHOICE is to SUBMIT to GOD. Take it or go to hell.

  2. Amir says:

    Specious logic -The Bogus argument-

    The claim that cold "doesn't exist" because according to the laws of physics it's merely "the absence of heat" amounts to semantic game-playing. Heat is a noun, the name of a physical phenomenon, a form of energy. Cold is an adjective, a description. To say that something is cold, or that we feel cold, or even that we're going out in "the cold," is not to assert that cold "exists." It's simply a way of describing the relative temperature of things. (It's helpful to recognize that the proper antonym for cold isn't heat; it's hot.)

    The same applies to light (in this context a noun denoting a form of energy), and dark (an adjective). It's true that when we say, "It's dark outside," the phenomenon we're actually describing is a relative absence of light, but that doesn't mean that by speaking of "the dark" we mistake it for a thing that "exists" in the same sense that light does. We're simply describing the degree of illumination we perceive.

    So it's a philosophical parlor trick to posit heat and cold (or light and dark) as a pair of opposite entities only to "reveal" that the second term doesn't really refer to an entity at all, but merely the absence of the first.

    The young Einstein would have known better, and so would his professor.
    http://urbanlegends.about.com/od/religion/a/einst

    • Luq says:

      Same way, God is noun and Evil is adjective. you actually proved the same point.

      • Amir says:

        Luq- Good not God can be juxtaposed with evil. You are making the same mistake as the kid did.The case, such as it is, has been built on the unpacking of purported opposites — heat vs. cold, light vs. dark. What's the opposite of evil? Good. To keep the argument consistent, the conclusion therefore ought to be: Evil doesn't exist because it's only a term we use to describe the absence of good.

        You may wish to claim that good is the presence of God in men's hearts, but in that case you'll have launched a whole new debate, not finished one.
        http://urbanlegends.about.com/od/religion/a/einst….

  3. Amir says:

    this is a bogus argument – some jehova's witness prepared this video-as well as a bogus story

    Analysis: This apocryphal tale of a college-age Albert Einstein proving the existence of God to his atheist professor first began circulating in 2004. One reason we know it isn't true is that the same story was already making the rounds five years earlier with no mention of Einstein in it at all.

    Another reason we know it isn't true is that Einstein was a self-described agnostic who didn't believe in what he called a "personal God." He wrote: "[T]he word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honorable but still primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childish."

    And, finally, we know it isn't true because Einstein was a careful thinker who wouldn't have abided the specious logic attributed to him here. As written, the argument neither disproves the existence of evil nor proves the existence of God.

    (Note: None of what follows is intended to disprove the existence of God, nor suffices to do
    http://urbanlegends.about.com/od/religion/a/einst

  4. Nonelitepakamerican says:

    Yes to test the people with the brains……

    Does evil exist?

    The university professor challenged his students with this question. Did God create everything that exists? A student bravely replied, "Yes, he did!"

    "God created everything? The professor asked.

    "Yes sir", the student replied.

    The professor answered, "If God created everything, then God created evil since evil exists, and according to the principal that our works define who we are then God is evil". The student became quiet before such an answer. The professor was quite pleased with himself and boasted to the students that he had proven once more that the Christian faith was a myth.

    Another student raised his hand and said, "Can I ask you a question professor?"

    "Of course", replied the professor.

    The student stood up and asked, "Professor, does cold exist?"

    "What kind of question is this? Of course it exists. Have you never been cold?" The students snickered at the young man's question.

    The young man replied, "In fact sir, cold does not exist. According to the laws of physics, what we consider cold is in reality the absence of heat. Every body or object is susceptible to study when it has or transmits energy, and heat is what makes a body or matter have or transmit energy. Absolute zero (-460 degrees F) is the total absence of heat; all matter becomes inert and incapable of reaction at that temperature. Cold does not exist. We have created this word to describe how we feel if we have no heat."

    The student continued, "Professor, does darkness exist?"

    The professor responded, "Of course it does."

    The student replied, "Once again you are wrong sir, darkness does not exist either. Darkness is in reality the absence of light. Light we can study, but not darkness. In fact we can use Newton's prism to break white light into many colors and study the various wavelengths of each color. You cannot measure darkness. A simple ray of light can break into a world of darkness and illuminate it. How can you know how dark a certain space is? You measure the amount of light present. Isn't this correct? Darkness is a term used by man to describe what happens when there is no light present."

    Finally the young man asked the professor, "Sir, does evil exist?"

    Now uncertain, the professor responded, "Of course as I have already said. We see it every day. It is in the daily example of man's inhumanity to man. It is in the multitude of crime and violence everywhere in the world. These manifestations are nothing else but evil."

    To this the student replied, "Evil does not exist sir, or at least it does not exist unto itself. Evil is simply the absence of God. It is just like darkness and cold, a word that man has created to describe the absence of God. God did not create evil. Evil is not like faith, or love that exist just as does light and heat. Evil is the result of what happens when man does not have God's love present in his heart. It's like the cold that comes when there is no heat or the darkness that comes when there is no light."

    The professor sat down.

    The young man's name — Albert Einstein.
    Read more at http://www.snopes.com/religion/einstein.asp#4UqCG

  5. Dost Ali says:

    Title is wrong bro. Albert Einstein did not say this but corrected this. In this video Albert Einstein is a child who replied and corrected the teacher who raised this false question.

  6. Iqbal says:

    Evil, in my opinion, is misuse of free will given by The Almighty and aligning oneself with Iblees (shaitan).

  7. KR57 says:

    Things are known by their opposites and were created in pairs with diverse shades and degrees.

  8. Amir says:

    But God created Satan or Shaitan. So evil is not absence of love of God, it is a physical thing created by God himself.

    • Devil says:

      Kids like to talk and especially if you are future Einstein. Yes, God created evil and it is called Shaitan. Now whether you want to follow Shaitan or not is another thing but if God did not create Shaitan, we will not experience evil.

    • Luq says:

      I hope this will clarify……… It seems you are Muslim and I hope you will know that Satan was actually a Jin (Created with Fire) or you can research. Just like good and evil Humans, Satan was actually an Evil Jin. And you had a very good explanation about noun and adjective, so God created Satan (Jin) but he is evil because he does not have good in him.

      PS. If you are not Muslim, then you do not have to agree or disagree to my comment.

      • Amir says:

        so you mean God created an adjective… from fire or clay, still a creation, a physical creation, I am not sure you understand what you are responding to?

        read below, Quran describes the entire event

        And behold, We said to the angels: “Bow down to Adam” and they bowed down. Not so Iblis (Satan): he refused and was haughty: he was of those who reject Faith. (2: 34)

        It is We Who created you and gave you shape; then We bade the angels bow down to Adam, and they bowed down; not so Iblis; He refused to be of those who bow down. (God) said: “What prevented thee from bowing down when I commanded thee?” He said: “I am better than he: Thou didst create me from fire, and him from clay.” (God) said: “Get thee down from this: it is not for thee to be arrogant here: get out, for thou art of the meanest (of creatures).” (7: 11–13)

        Behold! We said to the angels: “Prostrate unto Adam”: They prostrated except Iblis (Satan): He said, “Shall I prostrate to one whom Thou didst create from clay?” He said: “Seest Thou? This is the one whom Thou hast honoured above me! If Thou wilt but respite me to the Day of Judgment, I will surely bring his descendants under my sway – all but a few!” (17: 61–62)

        • Luq says:

          God created Angels, Jinns, Humans and everything else. Angels with Noor (Light), Jinns with Fire and Humans with clay.
          Angels can never be Evil/bad.
          Jinns can be Evil/bad.
          Humans can be Evil/bad.

          So being evil just shows that someone is not good.

      • Amir says:

        Luq-you obviously don't know the debate topic. Listen to the video one more time. I have a feeling the concept is not yet clear to you. That is why your responses make no sense.

        your earlier post-God is a noun and evil is an adjective ,so just like light and darkness, they cannot be compared in an argument . A noun cannot be copared to an adjective.It is a logical fallacy.You are proving the point I was making .I hope you try to understand first then post. .

        Being Muslim or not have nothing to do with agree or not agree. it is a theological debate. Since satan and Shaitan are derived from similar stories starting from Judaism, therefore I metioned Shaitan,the concept as we know it, you have to be more attentive.

        • Luq says:

          The teachers argument in the video is stupid to begin with, there is no doubt about it, the video is out of question. Not really defending the video,The discussion is whether Satan and Evil are two words for one thing You have to actually separate the two words, one is the creation while other is the attribute of the creation. For example , when we say an Evil man. Man is the creation and Evil just describes the man. Not all men are evil, similarly not all Jinns are Evil, but Satan is evil.

  9. for all those who are looking for a logic here, lemi ask you
    "have you seen GOD?" no one has i guess but still we do believe in GOD. that is what knows as FAITH
    all those who are saying that religion is a problem are truly misguided because if you are so logical and full of skills. TRY and live without oxygen. idiots

    HUM MAIN SAY KISI NAY ALLAH ko nahi daikha, phir be hum maantay hain k ALLAH hain aur MOHAMMAD S.A.W.W akhri RASOOL hain. issi ko imaan kehtay hain k bina daikhay janay bina partay bina jaanch hum un pay imaan laay
    is video main bhi ayhi dikhaya gya hai k einstein professor ko keh raha hai k khuda wahan nahi hota jahan insaan uss k hukam ko chaor k andheray raastay pay chal perta hai
    wallah alam uss any yeh kaha bhi hai ya nahi kiyun k gooray "zionists" her tarah say BILL GATES EINSTIEN ABRAHAM LINCOLN etc ko hero bana k dikhatay hain aur inka asal maqsad hamain hamray HEROES hamaray KHUFA-E-RASHIDEEN aur hamrai islami talimaat say door kerna hai
    einistien nay tou kaha hoga so hoga
    hamaray NABI S.A.W.W nay aaj say 1400 saal pehlaya bata diya tha k ay banday ager tu naik kaam keray ga tou khuda ka kurb hasil keray ga, ager ganday kaam keray ga tou shetaan ka sathi kehlaay ga

    and the Basic question which has been asked in the video that DID GOD created EVIL? for some reasons the answer is yes
    IBLEES THE DEVIL was the most respected angel when he was ordered to hail down to ADAM, he refused and turned his back and left the path which he was on. so what is the EVIL? AN ANGEL WHO TURNED BAD
    jo kuch bhi aasamaano aur zameen main hai, SAB ALLAH ka he hai (chaay woh insaan hain pahaar hain, jin ya gahir muslim jinaat. farishtay. sab ka khaliq wohi hai)
    yeh insaan k ikhtiyar main hai k woh kis raastay ko chunnay, ab hum qatil chor dakait bun jayain. ALLAH nay tou hamain insaan paida kiya tha. hum yeh tou nahi keh saktay k ALLAH nay haamin qatil banay ya choar ya daku.

  10. for all those who are looking for a logic here, lemi ask you
    "have you seen GOD?" no one has i guess but still we do believe in GOD. that is what knows as FAITH
    all those who are saying that religion is a problem are truly misguided because if you are so logical and full of skills. TRY and live without oxygen. idiots

    HUM MAIN SAY KISI NAY ALLAH ko nahi daikha, phir be hum maantay hain k ALLAH hain aur MOHAMMAD S.A.W.W akhri RASOOL hain. issi ko imaan kehtay hain k bina daikhay janay bina partay bina jaanch hum un pay imaan laay
    is video main bhi ayhi dikhaya gya hai k einstein professor ko keh raha hai k khuda wahan nahi hota jahan insaan uss k hukam ko chaor k andheray raastay pay chal perta hai
    wallah alam uss any yeh kaha bhi hai ya nahi kiyun k gooray "zionists" her tarah say BILL GATES EINSTIEN ABRAHAM LINCOLN etc ko hero bana k dikhatay hain aur inka asal maqsad hamain hamray HEROES hamaray KHUFA-E-RASHIDEEN aur hamrai islami talimaat say door kerna hai
    einistien nay tou kaha hoga so hoga
    hamaray NABI S.A.W.W nay aaj say 1400 saal pehlaya bata diya tha k ay banday ager tu naik kaam keray ga tou khuda ka kurb hasil keray ga, ager ganday kaam keray ga tou shetaan ka sathi kehlaay ga

    and the Basic question which has been asked in the video that DID GOD created EVIL? for some reasons the answer is yes
    IBLEES THE DEVIL was the most respected angel when he was ordered to hail down to ADAM, he refused and turned his back and left the path which he was on. so what is the EVIL? AN ANGEL WHO TURNED BAD
    jo kuch bhi aasamaano aur zameen main hai, SAB ALLAH ka he hai (chaay woh insaan hain pahaar hain, jin ya gahir muslim jinaat. farishtay. sab ka khaliq wohi hai)
    yeh insaan k ikhtiyar main hai k woh kis raastay ko chunnay, ab hum qatil chor dakait bun jayain. ALLAH nay tou hamain insaan paida kiya tha. hum yeh tou nahi keh saktay k ALLAH nay haamin qatil banay ya choar ya daku.
    ALLAH HO AKBAR

  11. Amir says:

    Does God exist? No, it's just an absence of an explanation -and a manufactured answer- by limited human mind.

    • Devil says:

      just like absence of light is darkness, according to the German speaking kid, absence of an explanation is God. Kid definitely does not know the can of worms he is opening.

  12. Overseas Pakistani says:

    Hats off for the answer

  13. Overseas Pakistani says:

    Religion is the base to create the problem not religion itself

  14. where ever there are more religious people in a country, those countries are fkd.Get rid of it plz.People who created religions fooled the people to get power money and girls

  15. Zohaib says:

    I feel very sorry for those who have commented by probably just reading out title and either there language competence is limited or there are totally illiterate. In this video, I can easily see the wonderful logic and a wonderful try to show that God does exist. And those of you who is against the logical findings, I would request them to kindly read through Quran properly where it is clearly written, "{Thus do we provide ayah (sign) for people who REFLECT} (Yunus 10: 24)".

    Jahil Qaum!

  16. Scarface says:

    no wonder he was Einstein
    he was such a smart kid

  17. gust says:

    E=MC2 THIS IS EINSTAIN,THESE PAKISTANIES CANT UNDERSTAND IT,THEY BELEIVE IN MULLAH AND THSSE MULLAH ARE ILLETRATE .THATS WHY ALAMA IQBAL SAID GALLA TO GHOT DEAIYA AHAL MADARSA NAY TARA,KAHA SAY AYA SADA LILAHA ILLAHA.

  18. Lord says:

    Of course. What we think as evil is created by Allah like evereything else. Evil in reality is transgressing from what Allah has ordained man and the ability to desire and make decisions and thus transgress in reality is the true evil.

  19. Tahir says:

    Don't qyarrel pls.it was einstein view that evil comes because of abscence of GOD'S love ,According to QURAN there was no evil forces in the universe but shaitan refused to obey GOD'S will and so become evil in jealousy.So he started every evil practice.Rule was simple just put direction of human's against the Will of GOD like him(shatan).So if a man love THE GOD so he will not go for wrong practice.So einstein was not wrong totally but evil exist and trying best to disobey humanity from ALLAH.

  20. aaa says:

    Israel wo wahid mulk hay jahan Khuda nay Sab say zeyada Prophets beghay or Pakistan Khanzeeer wo wahid mulk hay Jahan Khuda nay sab say zeyada Shaitan bheghay

  21. Quai e Azam says:

    UP LOADER AGAR TU MUSALMAN HAY TU TERI TAREEKH E PAIDAISH PAR LANAT.

    • Kaleem says:

      Beta aapko shayad english parhini nai aati! Zara parhiye to appko samajh aajayee k kitni logical baat ki thi Albert Einstein ne.

      • rafiq sabir says:

        I agree with u

      • Thaaaaaaaaaaaaa says:

        There are many so called logical ppl in world who even dont believe in God……….. So will you accept their logic too?……….
        Religion is something in which logic strengthen your faith and the logic presented in this video is completely illogical about the evil coz there is no connection of existence of physical things and mortal beings.
        There is sickness in some segments of our society they find logic in every thing which christian scientist's said even its a Darwin Theory of evolution…

  22. Nomi says:

    Laanat on the uploader whose iman is weak and is spreading the disease of doubt agar quran Praha Hota to ye sawal na karta or ye Einstein is history parho jahilo chor tha jo kaballah religion se tha jis mei shayateen or. Afreeton ki puja kartey hain again über laanat on uploader May Allah guide him

    • Zakir says:

      Laanti insaan tujhe iss ki samhaj bhi nahi ayee aur tu meray…. par carah raha hai. Alhamdulillah i know quran better then you. aur woh teacher kuch explain kar raha tha tu bache ne uss ko logically answer diya laant ho tum par. Jis ko video ke saath text ki samhaj tu nahi ayee au meray … par charh raha hai.

    • Umar Farooq says:

      lolx i think u didnt get the message… in this video shows that Albert believe in 1 God as he was born Jew. he is proving that God exists and God didnt created the evil. its the Man. who creates from his vision and power that God has gifted him. God has made man kind supeme of his all creations. humans do have unbelieveable powers that no other creatures of God can imagine.

      now regarding The kabbalah scripture! i have seen 1000 of conspiracy theories documentries but never heard that Albert was a Kabalaah believer. He was an extermly Jewish Believer.

      in wikipedia!!! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kabbalah
      "In the views of some Kabbalists this conceives 'evil' as a 'quality of God', asserting that negativity enters into the essence of the Absolute"

      Albert also said "Science is nothing without Religion". that means his all science is a CRAP without Religion & Believing in Gods existence.

      I dont support "albert einstein" nor the "video uploader". Just sharing my thought that My Quran Pak & Allah is the Superme of there kinds.

      and you should answer or criticize with Logic & Reason rather using Abusive lang. becouse when you open your mouth! it reflects your heart.

      Fe-Aman-Allah

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment, Register a free Account Now