8pm with Fareeha Idrees (Pakistan is Islamic state or secular country ?) – 15th August 2012



Zaid Hamid(Analyst), Amir Liaqat – 8pm with Fareeha Idrees 15th August 2012

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 8.1/10 (109 votes cast)
8pm with Fareeha Idrees (Pakistan is Islamic state or secular country ?) - 15th August 2012, 8.1 out of 10 based on 109 ratings

46 Comments Leave your comment

  1. imtiazs28 says:

    Agreed with ZAID HAMID

    we were made on Islam , We need islamic laws and Khilafat System

  2. imtiazs28 says:

    Why you ppl call DR. AMIR LIAQAT ( he is fake )

    he is a liar and fake person not trust worthy

  3. pakparast says:

    Pakistan is an Islamic country .. no one can change this fact.

    Pakistan have great potential, but its being ruined by the liberal elite.. the "Status Quo"

    But now we have to work hard to fulfill the dreams of our fore father by making Pakistan a true Islami Falahi Riyasat.

  4. mshahzadanjum says:

    Yeh buddhi hogai hy lekin iska make-up dekho. Yeh kia islam ki baat kre gi. Isko Islam se itni he takleef hy to dafa hojy Pakistan se. Pakistan doesnt need these cowards.

  5. tanveer6568 says:

    AoA..dear friends my name is tanveer, i am muslim, al hamdo lilah. i need contect number of Zaid Hamid. if any body know his contect number please send me as SMS on my number +966561479219 or e.mail. tanveer6568@yahoo.com

  6. SimplePak says:

    Why media invite people like amir liaqat n why media write 'MAZHABI scholar' and 'DR' in front of Amir Liaqat name….his DR degree is fake n from where he become mazhabi scholar…by watching GHALIB movie…Astaghfar…i am sure program khatam hone k baad amir liaqat ne kaha ho ga apne logo se….'KESE DIYA'…

  7. Mind Trust says:

    1- I failed to understand why a person like Amir Liaqat who is recognized as totally disrespectful personality is invited, he should've been boycotted from all TV channels.

    2- Zaid Hamid is on the righteous path and may Allah SWT give strength to all of us to be guided.

    3- Yes Caliphate will return back as there are predictions available.

    4- Many times Dr. Israr Ahmed (RA) (may Allah forgive him and raise his Darajaat) in his lectures ask every Muslim to struggle towards the right State, that is Khilafat.

  8. navobot says:

    I support Dr. Farzana and Dr. Aamir Liaqat. Zaid Hamid appears an extremist to me.

  9. moon143 says:

    Zaid Hamid is stubborn. let decide people what they want . Plz don,t waste time and everyone should be free for his religion practice.

  10. Janbaz says:

    great to see Zaid sb…. he is true ideological representative of youth of this country…

  11. GHAYYUR.JANJUA says:

    ZAID HAMID IS IDEALOGICAL HERO OF YOUTH.

  12. Malangi says:

    عامر لیاقت تم صرف عورتوں کی کال سنا کرو زیداحمد سے تمارا نالج بہت کم ہے ۔

    نہ تو تم سلام اور نہ ہی اقبال کو اتنا جانتے ہو جتنا زیداحمد ۔

  13. naeemg3 says:

    Dear Zaid Hamid You are the lion of Pakistan. You are truthful others two are

    mixing lies to confuse the nation. I salute you, I pray for you.

  14. Zahidsolo says:

    System Of Khulfa-Rashdeen will not be possible because of time difference.

    Law is given by Great ALLAH in Quran, Details can be settled by Government, Profit Mohammed (PBUH) the great last profit was also following the Law of ALLAH, All the Profits before Profit Mohammed (PBUH) were also following the Law of ALLAH. Like

    1- Every one must be away from SHIRK

    2- Parents must be treated in best way

    3- Adultery is not allowed at all

    4- One should say justice even if it effect himself

    5- Peoples should obey their honest Leades

    And Much more from Quran

  15. honest1 says:

    IMRAN ki shakal mien hi ALLAH ne hamaray lia aik nijat dandah bejha ha…jo hamay

    is gandey .gallay….sarray…ghaleez….nizam..aur..sab parties…aur un ke.jhotey.makkar.munafiq..aur.lutery leadro..se..nijat.dilay.ga..INSHALAH.

    ye be waqt ki behas ha…kia nizam hona chahay..pehlay mulk mien insaf aam karo

    social justice karo..ghareeb ko izzat..aur rooti do..us ki izzat ki hafazat karo then

    talk about nizam please………

  16. ahmadz says:

    The reason Pakistan was created so the system introduced by Prophet Muhammad PBUH in Madina could be re-introduced here. Hazrat Allama Muhammad Iqbal Rahimahullah knew that the only person who can make his vision (of Khilafat ala Manhaj al Nabuwah) a glowing reality is M A Jinnah. At the same time, he was worried about the fate of the country after Jinnah because only a handful of people understood the reason behind its creation. Iqbal knew that the people who will come after him and Jinnah might let them down and even harm the country. That anxiety grew even more in his last days. Dr Israr Ahmed Rahimahullah compared the pain of Iqbal with that of Zakaria (AS) when he prayed to Allah (SWT) to give him a son. So it doesn't surprise me when Zaid Hamid came to tears because he realizes that what the worst Iqbal feared became true.

    Its very hard for an average reader of Quran (like me) and someone who studied Objective resolution, to digest the mindset of Farzana Bari. She calls Pakistan a secular state which means that 5 million people who sacrificed their lives just so the people after them are not persecuted for proclaiming "La Ilaha Illa Allah". If that is not an insult to the martyrs then what is? I condemn her words to fullest extent and pray that Allah SWT grant the martyrs the highest rank in Jannah. Ameen Ya Rabb al Alameen.

    I am surprised at the level of knowledge that Amir Liaquat has. He is ill informed about the history of Islam on one hand and on the other hand, he has the audacity of saying that "Hazrat Umar RA gave the keys of Jerusalem to the Jews by telling them that it is their city". Naoozo Billah. Why would Hazrat Umar do that. Doesnt he know what the Quran has said in Surat Al Anbiya Verse 104

    وَلَقَدۡ ڪَتَبۡنَا فِى ٱلزَّبُورِ مِنۢ بَعۡدِ ٱلذِّكۡرِ أَنَّ ٱلۡأَرۡضَ يَرِثُهَا عِبَادِىَ ٱلصَّـٰلِحُونَ

    And We have written in Zabur (Psalms) after the advice that the land will be inherited by My righteous servants

    Through out the Quran, we read how the Israelites were given strength on earth but they in their arrogance, disobeyed Allah but obeyed the decisions of their tribal chiefs and Rabbis so Allah destroyed them. Allah describes about them in Surat al Ghafir Verse 20

    أَوَلَمۡ يَسِيرُواْ فِى ٱلۡأَرۡضِ فَيَنظُرُواْ كَيۡفَ كَانَ عَـٰقِبَةُ ٱلَّذِينَ كَانُواْ مِن قَبۡلِهِمۡۚ كَانُواْ هُمۡ أَشَدَّ مِنۡہُمۡ قُوَّةً۬ وَءَاثَارً۬ا فِى ٱلۡأَرۡضِ فَأَخَذَهُمُ ٱللَّهُ بِذُنُوبِہِمۡ وَمَا كَانَ لَهُم مِّنَ ٱللَّهِ مِن وَاقٍ۬

    Have they not travelled in the land and seen what was the end of those who were before them? They were superior to them in strength, and in the traces in the land. But Allâh seized them with punishment for their sins. And none had they to protect them from Allâh

    Doesnt Amir Liaquat know what happened to the People of Noah AS, the People of Lot AS, Sodom and Gomorrah, People of Mosa (Bani Israel). They even tried to execute Nabi Isa AS but Allah saved him from that humiliating punishment. He kicked them out of Jerusalem, scattered them all over the earth and barred them from ever entering the land. But Amir Liaquat claims that that Hazrat Umar RA gave the keys to the Jews which means he defied Prophet Muhammad SAW. That allegation on Umar RA is uncalled for and he should make repent on his mistake for attributing this to him.

  17. spy eye says:

    nonsense suits on amir liyaqat ali…Pakistan is Islamic State nd ll b always INSHALLAH…we need Pakistan as Islamic Welfare State, others all nonsense like farzana nd amir liyaqat

  18. alisherdil says:

    this begerat.commercial.amir liaaqat.distorting history……

    …… beherat adami …..

    ….first…… when muslims.conquered Bait ul Muqadas(jjersalem) at the time of Hazrat Omar r.a.it was ruled by Romans n they were Christians not jews.

    2nd……it were christians.who.asked.they will.handover keys.pf.Jerisalem to muslims.if their khalifa.hazrat.Omar.will.come.himself so hazrat Omar went there.

    ……3rd……hazrat omar a.s went with lord priest to grand catgedral of jerusalem and very tht time Asar salaat time was n.sahabas n.priest asked to pray in cathedral but hazrat Omar refused as if a i say Salaaat here then my successirs ll make it as Rawayatt to offer salaat in cathedral.

    hazrat omar never handed over keys of jerusalem to jews rather in contrast It were Ruling christians who handed over keys to hazart Omar r.a.

    amir luaqat begerati kar raha hae jst lieing … history ….. Typical geo propaganda machinery.

  19. Aizyv says:

    If people like zaid hamid become rulers there wont be freedom of speech and who ever criticise or disagrees with his opinions or analysis will be called a ghaddar desh drohi traitor un patriotic islam dushman etc

    • calico says:

      Most do,t have food to survive, you worried about freedom of speech ?

      Worse than Taliban, PPP/PML/MQM, Generals—Wives swapping parasites.

      PPP/PML/MQM/ANP/Army (Main Architect supports corrupt system by design.

      Victims: Foot soldiers and Innocent Public and Western countries

      Beneficiaries: Political leadership and Army General—wives swapping parasites

      What People of Pakistan got?????????

      Accountability Bill: PPP/PML together on 17th, 18th, 20th, never passed ,

      Dirty Drinking Water— Hepatitis C

      Dirty Hospital— Leader (PIGS) treated oversees, No infrastructure, less pay for staff.

      Education system: classes held in graveyards, poultry farms, ghost schools.

      Fake medicine—Political poodles involved in drug industry, Mosa, Hanif, (Ephedrine)

      Law and Order: No protection for common man while nothing happened to MNA, MPA, etc.

      No Electricity: 15 to 20 hours, no light, no work, Rental Raja.

      No Gas: cooking food is a problem.

      No jobs: Most of industries run on electricity.

      Poverty: Public poor, leaders flying & buying properties oversees with stolen money.

      Price hike: corruption is compensated by price hike, for rich PIGS– Mayfair, and surrey Palace.

      Sewerage system—Gutter water is mixed with drinking water—Hepatitis C

      Sold out Media: Never asked question about above mentioned issues.

  20. Aizyv says:

    Khalifa means ruler khilafat means government khilfate rashidah means the time period of first 4 rulers in islam as after that it turned into family kingdoms.Islam doesnt give any political system.During khilafate rashidah when 1 ruler used to die people used to gather and select a ruler and many used to oppose it cz of which all of them were killed by fellow muslims and divided muslims into shiya sunni.Islam has few economic rules like there shouldnt be interest on loans,wealth should circulate through collecting zakat or jizya which is called taxes these days nothing else.There are so many sects in islam every sect has different interpretation of Quran and hadis so when some1 says they want shariah it means their interpretation of Quran.So dont listen to these crazy people like zaid hamid.As u saw in this program he was saying stuff against deobandis.i dont belong to any sect but shariah will just increase secterianism

  21. manu02 says:

    Amir Liaqat you are non sense …. Amir Liaqat tumnay ghalib film dekhe ha …. lolx

    • tariq1985 says:

      Amir Liaqat:

      Pakistan was not to be a secular state.

      Pakistan was to be a state where all people from all religious beliefs could live without fear of persecution.

      Jack Ass! That is a secular state.

      Dr Farzanai:

      Pakistan was not made for Islam.

      Pakistan was made for muslims of India.

      To do what? practice Islam or just a separate state so we could have a separate cricket team from India.

      Fareeha is wasting Zaid Hamid`s time by inviting these two morons to the show.

  22. muistar says:

    This is nonsense. Zaid hamid you duffer misguide the people in the name of Islam even you don’t understand what you saying. Why you don’t say to the people that Quaid e azam was secular not a fundamentalist, and by sect he was shia and people like you consider shias as kafir. And why you scare to say that sir Zafarulla khan which had key role in construction of Pakistan Resolution was Qadyani (Ahmadi). Now tell me, is Khilafaterashida possible in present circumstances? How it will come, through democracy or through dictatorship? Who will be the leader of Khilafat? You agree or disagree this is your personal matter but now you can’t hide the real history from young generation. Pakistan was made as a Muslim social welfare state, not Islamic state. Suppose if it was come in to being in the name of Islam then why millions of Muslims of that time in India didn’t join them. And why majority of Islamic scholars of that time didn’t agree with this fake ideology. Then why this ideology fails to sustain Bangladesh as a part of Pakistan. So this is your ideology don’t try to stick it to Pakistan. Don’t puzzle the people any more, don’t use the name of Islam to dictate others, religion is a personal matter. It is better to shut your mouth and if you still confuse debate with marvi surmad or Hasan nisar they will clear you about all these things.

  23. Zahidsolo says:

    It does not depend even on Qaida-Azam , Pakistan is Muslim Majority , Rules here will be muslim Islamic rules.

    If Dr.Farzana will read Quran then she will know .

  24. ansari says:

    WE WANT ILAMIC LAW IN PAKISTAN

    KHULFAYE RASHDIN ZINDA BAD

  25. Usman says:

    Bigger Non-Sense by self ZAID HAMID :P

    • saam khan says:

      i m in doubt about what non sence u have found in him mr usman coame across inshaALlah i m sure u will be a better muslim why we use to say such people non sence who are talking for islam ND FROM QURQN TRY TO READ AND UNDERSTAND QURAN BOHAT AASANI HO JAYE AAP K LIYE

      • Usman says:

        Who are you to give me the Certificate of Islam… or better Muslim? hnn? Zaid Hamid is a extremist person won't listen any person and give such a hard remarks for others… :P

  26. alisherdil says:

    salam guyz …. its our greatest misfortune that peoples likr Amir liaqat …. is so called scholar …. he is a…z fake as

    … his doctorate degree os fale ( on.behalf.he.os called doctor)

    … he is commercial fake religious man.jst selling Din fot Dunya.

    ….n..about his chracter …. i wont see.jst loook.his Golden.views.on you tube.

    we Pakistanis r ruined in matter.of Din.coz.we.handed….Islam to.peoples like.Amir liaqat … n.we dont search n study.islam our selves.

  27. muhammad00900 says:

    What a rubbish nonsense talks are going on we genuinely know very well it was made to established khilafah purely on Islamic basis . Who dont knows that . Media people are all corrupt and sold working on salaries and trying to misguide people . Stupids.

    Salute to Zaid Hamid not because of hes my fren but your delivering truth .

  28. designer.pk says:

    Aslaam-o-ALiqum

    sab saypehlay Allah ka shukar karta hoon kay us nay humain pak sarzameen aata ki aur is sarzameen ko napak logo say bachanay kay liye kuch log bhi aata kiye.Ye sawal ka matlab samjhna ho to jao un azeem mother kay azeem jawano say pochoo jo ab bhi jahad fi sabeel Allah par believe kartay hain aur aik nara-e-takbeer par apni jaanay qurbaan kartay aaye hain aur Insha Allah kartay rahain gay.koi un maoon say poochay jo apnay lal Allah kay naam par qurbaan karti aaye hain aur karti rahain gi.Ye jo human right walay hain in say poochoo to zara oo bhai Jis nay tum ko paida kiya hai us say ziada rights kon day ga tum ko . Aik aur baat human rights ki baat sirf in jaisi third class hi kion karti hain. Mujhay maaf karna itna lafz bola par mujhay batao bhaio kay jis aik umeed pay hum ji rahay hain yani islam us par bhi koi attack karay ga to main kiya karon. Aik umeed hai kay sab muslim aik parcham Islam kay neechay akhtay hon gay us ko bhi khatam karnay pay lagay hain ye log aur pakistan ko islam say alehda kiya ja sakta hi nahi hai kion kay ye paak sarzameen sirf islam kay liye hasil ki gaye thi aur di gaye thi (Allah ki taraf say) aur humaisha Insha Allah islam ki hi rahay gi in jaisi khatoon jo marzi kar lain.

  29. Mo says:

    pakistan ka matlab kiya jhoot faraib aur dhoka

    pakistani ka maltab kiya be ghar nanga bhooka

    pakistan ki hukumat kiya chor daku bhik manga

    pakistan ka qanoon kiya badmashon ka istisna

    pakistan ke din raat kiya din me tare raat andhera

    pakistan me mazhab kiya maal banne ka zarya

  30. Hamid says:

    Indian Muslim's Predictions About Pakistan Coming True.Pakistan has done remarkably well to prove Maulana Azad's predictions correct. LOL!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1zPt7C-4o8

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqXEy1GhAcI

  31. ssulehria1 says:

    Quaid-e-Azam, also said that although Pakistan is now formed but I feel some fake coins in my pocket. Unfortunately, those “fake coins” are now in the government.

  32. ug116 says:

    Agreed with Zaid Hamid. His is representing the sacifices of the Muslims for the creation of Pakistan. Pakistan is an ideological state and an Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

  33. Mo says:

    pakistan sirf aik lanati mulk ha aur bas

    • shezbaig says:

      Jub kisi pe lanat kee jatee hai, jo uska haqdar nahi hota, to lanat us par hee palat jatee hai, jis ne kee hotee hai.

      Is liye buhat darna chahiyay lanat buhat baree cheez hai, itnee asani se nahi istemal karnee chahiyay.

  34. medocrate says:

    I have no doubt that Zaid Hamid seems to be a patriotic person but just being patriotic is not enough because all the suicide Bombers are also patriotic thatswhy they sacrifice their Lives. Along with patriotism , We also need to be sensible, Logical and Realistic. Zaid hamid type people have damaged this country on the name of Islam and on the name of unrealistic Patriotism . He is Extra poetic , over emotional , unrealistic , Illogical , Extremist who has no tolerance and common sense but lives in a theoretical world and Superiority Complex . He preaches impracticality and Idealism .

  35. bluesky says:

    marvi sirmed hoti to maza ata program ka.

  36. itishan says:

    Assalamoalaikum to every MUSLIM

    PAKISTAN KA MATLIB KIAA ??????????????????????'

    LA-ILAHA-ILL-ALLAH

    Yehi woh naaraa thaa jiss ki bunyaad par pakistan banaa thaa , isi kalmay kai liye lakhun logun nay shahadat pai,

    ZAID HAMID SAHIB se hamm 100 % agree hain , Agar secular state banana thi too indiaa se hamm kiun alaihdaa huai, india bhi ti aik secular state kaa dawa kartaa hai, iss liye nay country ki too zarurat hi naheen thi ,

    FARZANA BARI aur namnihad secular logun se TWO NATION THEORY par sawal karnaa chahye,

    INN KO agar ISLAMIC REPUBLIC PAKISTAN naheen pasand too PAKISTAN ki sarzameen chor dain , aur jehaan inn ko panaah milty hai wahaan chalai jain,

    PAKISTAN KA MATLIB KIAA LAILAHA-ILLALLAH

    PAKISTAN ZINDA BAD

    QAIDEAZAM PAINDA BAD

    ZAID HAMID LIVE LONG

    ALLAH HAFIZ

  37. Pak-zindabad says:

    sab say palay farzana bari sahiba ka to na deen hai na imaan. dosri baat yeh anchor sirf apna program interesting karnay k lyeh sirf or sirf bullshit questions poochti na koi logic na koi common sense. pakistan k problems ki solution doondnay k bajye yeh bagairat anchors apnay show ki ratings badanay k chakar may her din lagay rehtay hain..

  38. leo78 says:

    isss zalil aurat ko sheeday tali aur zaida hamid kay ilwa koi aur nai milta

    • saam khan says:

      mughay bohat dukh hota hai k jab mai apni aankho k samnay khuda oor rasool (pbuh) ki baat ko itni deedadalairi say radd hotay dekhta hu yani k hum ic hadd takk mafloooj ho gaye hai k hum yeh sunna hi nahi chahtay khuda oor rasool kanizam kiya hai mughay dukh hota hai k jo nizaam hamai Allah or uc k rasool nay ata kiya hua hai hum uc ko nafiz to kiya uc ko sunnay say hi qassir hai here i m very sorry to say from u all guys quran ko parrho mai yeh nahi kehta k zaid sahab sahi keh rahay hai but compare karro yaar khud kia Allah or uc k rasool nay hamai mukammal zaabta e hayaat nahi baaya islami muaashra kesa hona chaiye dukh ic cheeze ka hai hamari quraan say doori ic qadar ho gai hai k hum logo nay yeh so called scholars ko hi dharam maan liya hai khuda k liye hum sub azaab mai jakrray huay hai aik aayat mai aata hai khuda taaala farmatay hai k hum ic baat pay qadir hai k tum ko tum hi say larra dain yani k tum mai ikhtilaaf ki jang peda kar dain oor tum kiya jano k aapas ki larrai ka dukh kesa hota hai Allah kami beshi maaf farmaye meray bhaiyo meri behnii khudara quraan say talluq jorro warna hum gharoo mai aik nahi rahain gay this is my humble request to all of u and at first i want to pray for me k ALlah mughay ic quran ko samaghnay ki tofeeq ata karray amin jazakAllaho khair

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment, Register a free Account Now